Bethany Joy Lenz Emily Assiran/Getty Images for That’s 4 Entertainment
One Tree Hill alum Bethany Joy Lenz has been candid about her “recovery” after a decade in a cult.
“I was in a cult for 10 years,” Lenz said during a July 2023 episode of her “Drama Queens” podcast, which she cohosts with fellow OTH stars Hilarie Burton Morgan and Sophia Bush. “That would be a really valuable experience to write about, and the recovery — 10 years of recovery after that. So, there’s a lot to tell.”
Lenz ultimately detailed her experience as a part of The Big House Family cult in her Dinner for Vampires memoir, released in October 2024.
“I feel proud of it. People often ask me, are you excited? And I’m thinking excited is not the right adjective because it’s not a story that I was ever really dying to tell,” Lenz said of the book on the “Call Her Daddy” podcast in October 2024, noting that after many conversations with women she decided that writing a book was “the right thing to do.”
For the cast of One Tree Hill, the line between fact and fiction was often blurred. The show’s stars claim that events from their real lives — from their personal interests to their traumas — would find their way into their characters’ storylines. “[The producers] made practice of taking advantage of people’s personal lives,” Sophia […]
Keep scrolling to find out what else Lenz has said about her cult experience — and how she left:
July 2023
“I think the ADHD has made it really difficult over the years to — I have lots of essays and lots of chapters and things,” Lenz said on “Drama Queens” of her desire to write about her past. “But to really commit to putting it all together, I would love to write about my experience.”
Lenz, who fronts the band Everly, noted that she also channeled her emotions on the subject into song.
Bethany Joy Lenz Jamie McCarthy/WireImage
August 2023
Lenz first got involved with the organization one or two years after she landed the role of Haley James Scott on OTH, which premiered in September 2003. Her experience in the Big House Family was common knowledge to her costars.
“For a while, they were all trying to save me and rescue me, which is lovely and so amazing to be cared about in that way. But I was very stubborn,” she recalled to Variety. “I was really committed to what I believed were the best choices I could make. … The nature of a group like that is isolation; they have to make you distrust everyone around you so that the only people you trust are, first and foremost, the leadership and then, people within the group if the leadership approves of them, and isn’t in the middle of pitting you against each other, which happens all the time also.”
She further told Variety that filming OTH in North Carolina helped her gain a “spatial separation” from the “bible-based cult” that helped her ultimately decide to leave.
Sometimes all you need is one … podcast. From the moment that Hilarie Burton, Bethany Joy Lenz and Sophia Bush launched the “Drama Queens” podcast, they started spilling One Tree Hill secrets. The actresses, who starred in the hit CW series as Peyton, Haley and Brooke, respectively, launched the podcast in June 2021 to recap […]
September 2023
Before leaving the Big House Family, Lenz reached her “breaking point.”
“There’s a lot of highs and lots of lows and at some point, you just are like, ‘Can I get off this ride, please? What’s wrong with me? Why am I so up and down all the time?’” she told E! News. “And sometimes it just takes a few people at the right moment saying, ‘It might not be anything wrong with you.’ And that can be a relief.”
Lenz continued, “I had lost a lot of [my faith] along the way. And one of my prayers was just sort of like, ‘You have to just meet me where I am because I don’t even know if I know who you are anymore,’ and that’s how God just kept showing up for me in spite of the fact that I was thrusting a middle finger up in the air and being like, ‘Screw you!’”
October 2023
Lenz revealed on The Tamron Hall Show that she was first drawn to the group for a bible study-type atmosphere.
“That just felt natural and normal to me,” she said. “I grew up stomping around the city. I lived in Jersey and I was an only child and my parents, wonderful people, had their own things going on and … I felt like I didn’t have a huge connection to family or community.”
Bethany Joy Lenz Jason Kempin/Getty Images for PEOPLE x IHG Hotels and Resorts
Lenz, as a result, sought a “place that felt safe” after moving to Los Angeles from New York.
“It seemed really lovely at the top,” she said, before noting that she eventually felt isolated from her OTH costars and her parents. “[But,] I felt like I was being loved. They start to convince you that you’re amazing, you’re wonderful and then they tear you down and start picking at all the little things … until you feel like nothing, and then they start to build you back up again. It’s like, ‘These people love me in spite of the fact that I’m just such a mess.’”
February 2024
She announced her memoir via Instagram, calling the cult “an abusive, high-demand group.”
“Being a writer has been a great, private joy in my life since I was about 12. This isn’t the first book I thought I’d write, publicly, but as difficult as this subject matter is to untangle, I’m grateful I get to share my story my way,” she added. “It’s a story of forgiveness and a roadmap to how manipulation works, with heartache and humor along the way. We all make mistakes and I hope Dinner for Vampires reminds you that, no matter what weird roads you’ve gone down, you’re not alone.”
October 2024
Lenz was married to the cult leader’s son during her time as a member of The Big House Family. While she often questioned the marriage, she never questioned the situation she was in — and even tried to justify being in a cult.
“I was very young, I didn’t question the group, [but] I questioned my marriage,” she told People. “For me, being involved in something like that where there’s — I don’t know that I like the term ‘brainwashing’ — I think it’s more just such high control that we convince ourselves of things all the time.”
Sometimes all you need is one … podcast. From the moment that Hilarie Burton, Bethany Joy Lenz and Sophia Bush launched the “Drama Queens” podcast, they started spilling One Tree Hill secrets. The actresses, who starred in the hit CW series as Peyton, Haley and Brooke, respectively, launched the podcast in June 2021 to recap […]
In the book, Lenz leaves her ex unnamed, calling him “QB.” She further detailed their relationship on “Call Her Daddy,” revealing that they were put on a sex schedule by the cult leaders after a lack of connection in their relationship.
October 2024
The actress also detailed her “terrifying” decision to leave the cult during her “Call Her Daddy” episode. Lenz recalled her friends in the group turning on her.
“To have your best friends who you’ve shared your most vulnerable, intimate secrets with suddenly turn around and overnight just, that’s it — if you’re not with us, you’re against us. If you’re not part of us, you’re the enemy,” she said. “To be treated like an enemy from someone who you’ve been very, very close with all of a sudden, no conversation. … There just was no willingness to see, because the stakes are so high for them too.”
